CCLA's Report on Police Records Checks

This press release provides a summary of CCLA’s 2014 report False promises, hidden costs: the case for reframing employment and volunteer police record check practices in Canada. The report argues that Canadians are being needlessly excluded from educational, volunteer and work opportunities based on irrelevant information disclosed on police record checks. The report questions the value of widespread police record checks and shines a light on the damaging individual and societal consequences of current practices. search report that examines current questions on the topic of religious freedom and its intersection with equality. The report first sets out a framework that guides the analysis before focusing on three specific areas: religious freedom and the rights of LGBT individuals, religious freedom and reproductive rights, and religious freedom as expressed in appearance. Through the examination of a sampling of key cases, the authors strive to articulate principles and recommendations that can guide advocates and policymakers towards a rights-based resolution of these debates.

What Is Disclosed In a Record Check? 

Record checks are increasingly used in the hiring process, and gaps in legislatures allow these checks to disclose information well beyond criminal convictions. This information may include:

  • Mental health apprehensions
  • Police records of suicide attempts
  • Complaints where charges were never laid
  • Withdrawn charges
  • Acquittals
  • Victim and witness information
Press Release

Download a copy of our press release, with a summary of our recommendations.

DOWNLOAD THE PRESS RELEASE
Report Recomendations

Governments should:

  • Introduce legislative and policy measures to prohibit the disclosure of non-conviction records;
  • Establish a centralized, evidence-based vulnerable sector screening process that incorporates human rights and privacy safeguards;
  • Recognize that it is in the public interest to support individuals with criminal records to find employment, and eliminate unjustifiable record check requirements mandated by legislation, government contracts, government policies, funding agreements, etc.; and
  • Amend legislation to ensure all Canadians enjoy the same levels of privacy and human rights protection in the workplace.

Our Latest Work and Updates

Filter

AllAccess to InformationArbitrary DetentionArtificial IntelligenceBill 21Bill 28Bill C-27Border TechnologyCases and LawsCCPA (Bill C-11)Community SupervisionConditions of ConfinementConstitutional RemediesCOVID-19COVID-19 & Law EnforcementCOVID-19 & PrisonsCRIMINAL JUSTICECriminal Prohibitions on SpeechCriminal Records & Collateral ConsequencesCriminal Records & Police Record ChecksCriminal Records & Police Record ChecksCruel & Unusual PunishmentDeaths in CustodyDecriminalizationDeescalation & Use of ForceDefamationDemocratic RightsDetasking PoliceDevice SearchesDisabilityDNA ForensicsDONATEEDUCATIONElection FinanceEmergencies ActEmergencies Act NewsEQUALITYFace SurveillanceFair Trial RightsFair Trial, Due Process & SentencingFighting Compelled Political SpeechFighting Solitary ConfinementFreedom of AssociationFreedom of ExpressionFreedom of ReligionFreedom of the PressFRONT BURNER ISSUESFUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMSGET INFORMEDGuidesIN THE NEWSINCLOIndigenous PeopleInformation SharingIntelligence & CybersecurityInternet Privacy and SpeechLearnLGBTQ2S+MAJOR CASES & REPORTSMass SurveillanceMobilityNational SecurityNB Abortion RightsNot Criminally ResponsibleOntario Private Sector LegislationOpen CourtsPIPEDAPODCASTPolice Coercion & EntrapmentPolice Powers, Use of Force & Police AccountabilityPolice Transparency, Oversight & AccountabilityPolicy 713Political AdvertisingPRESS RELEASESPresumption of InnocencePrisons, Jails & Community SupervisionPRIVACYPrivacy ActPrivacy During COVIDPrivacy Law ReformProsecutorial MisconductProtecting JournalistsRace, Religion & EthnicityRacial ProfilingReasonable Expectations of PrivacyRefugees & ImmigrationRegulation of Online ExpressionRight to CounselRight to ProtestRight to Reasonable BailRight to SilenceSafe SheltersSearch & SeizureSearch & SeizureSentencingSex Offender RegistriesSmart CitiesSocial MediaSocio-Economic StatusSolitary ConfinementStrip SearchesSurveillance & PrivacySurveillance & TechnologySurveillance CapitalismTalk RightsToronto's Smart CityTravel ScreeningUncategorizedUnreasonable Search & SeizureVaccine PassportsVOLUNTEERVoting RightsWomenYouth

Join Us As We Stand Against Bill 21 and for Human Rights

February 24, 2022
This is a critical moment.

CCLA Granted Leave to Challenge Arbitrary Travel Restrictions Before the SCC

April 26, 2024
Arbitrary travel restrictions infringe on the mobility rights of Canadians. CCLA’s challenge of Newfoundland government’s…

CCLA Joins Call from Civil Society to Withdraw AIDA from Bill C-27

April 25, 2024
AIDA is a disaster for privacy and human rights. The Parliamentary process is a disaster…

CCLA Calls on the Ontario Speaker to Lift His Ban on Keffiyehs

April 25, 2024
TORONTO — Anaïs Bussières McNicoll, Director of Fundamental Freedoms for the Canadian Civil Liberties Association…

CCLA Calls on Toronto Police Services Board to Act on Chief Demkiw’s Statement on Zameer Verdict

April 25, 2024
TORONTO — Shakir Rahim, Director of Criminal Justice for The Canadian Civil Liberties Association made…

Freedom of Association: SCC Confirms that the Same Test Applies to Positive and Negative Rights Claims

April 23, 2024
On April 19, 2024, the Supreme Court of Canada rendered its decision in the Société…

CCLA to Defend Democratic Rights Before the Supreme Court of Canada in Working Families Case

April 17, 2024
The Supreme Court of Canada just granted CCLA leave to intervene in the Attorney general…

CCLA Intervening before Ontario Court of Appeal to Oppose Standardless Limitless Searches of Personal Electronic Devices at Border

April 15, 2024
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association will appear this week before the Court of Appeal for…

CCLA Intervening Before Ontario Superior Court to Oppose Keeping Officer Names Secret in Police Accountability Cases

April 9, 2024
TORONTO — The CCLA will appear today before the Ontario Superior Court of Justice as an…

CCLA Deeply Concerned Over City of Kingston Encampment Evictions

April 5, 2024
TORONTO — CCLA is deeply concerned over the City of Kingston’s attempts to enforce a…

Ontario Court Finds Provisions of Safe Streets Act Unconstitutional

April 2, 2024
TORONTO — The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has found that the Safe Streets Act violates the Charter freedoms of unhoused people…

CCLA intervening before Superior Court of Justice to ensure fair adjudication of police complaints

April 2, 2024
The CCLA will appear before the Ontario Superior Court of Justice as an intervenor in…

Bill 124 confirmed unconstitutional by the Ontario Court of Appeal as regards unionized employees

March 21, 2024
The Protecting a Sustainable Public Service for Future Generations Act, 2019 (Bill 124) limited wage…

CCLA Granted Leave to Intervene at Supreme Court

March 19, 2024
TORONTO — Harini Sivalingam, Director of the Equality Program of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association,…

CCLA Argues Before the Quebec Court of Appeal in Landmark Racial Profiling Case

March 5, 2024
MONTREAL — The Canadian Civil Liberties Association will appear before the Court of Appeal of Quebec…

Supreme Court of Canada rules Police Now Required to Obtain Warrants for IP Address Access

March 1, 2024
Following the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Bykovets, Noa Mendelsohn Aviv, Executive Director and…

CCLA Reacts to Bill 21

February 29, 2024
MONTREAL — Today the Court of Appeal has issued a disappointing decision rejecting the constitutional challenge…

CCLA Urges Substantial Amendments to the Online Harms Act

February 28, 2024
TORONTO — Following the Government of Canada’s reintroduction of the Online Harms Act (Bill C-63), Noa Mendelsohn Aviv, Executive…

CCLA releases major report on bail system in Canada

February 26, 2024
CCLA is releasing its latest report on the bail system in Canada today, Still Failing:…

CCLA Intervenes in Jacob v Canada

February 23, 2024
TORONTO — Harini Sivalingam, Director of the Criminal Justice Program of the Canadian Civil Liberties…

CCLA intervenes on parliamentary privilege and democracy

February 22, 2024
CCLA is intervening in a motion on Parliamentary privilege and when courts may review decisions…